Most clients ask what a matter will cost before they ask anything else, and they are right to. The answer depends less on the hourly rate than on how the fee is structured. At Sterling & Cole LLP we use three structures: hourly on a retainer, fixed fee, and contingency or a hybrid of the two. Each suits a different kind of work, and each puts risk in a different place. This note explains how they work, when we propose each one, and what you should ask before you sign an engagement letter with any firm, including ours.
Why the structure matters more than the rate
A low hourly rate on an open-ended matter can cost more than a higher rate on a well-scoped one. What you are really buying is predictability, and predictability depends on two things: how well the work can be defined at the start, and who carries the risk if it grows.
Some work is easy to define. Drafting a will, reviewing an executive employment agreement, preparing a shareholder agreement for a company with three owners: we have done these many times, we know the steps, and we can price them in advance. Other work cannot be defined, because the other side decides how much of it there will be. Litigation is the obvious example. If the opposing party files four motions instead of one, the work quadruples, and no honest firm can tell you on day one how many motions there will be.
The fee structure should follow that distinction. When it does not, one side ends up subsidising the other, and that tends to show up later as friction over invoices.
The three structures, side by side
| Hourly on retainer | Fixed fee | Contingency or hybrid | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How you pay | Time recorded in six-minute units, billed monthly against a deposit | One agreed price for a defined scope, often in stages | A percentage of any recovery, sometimes with a reduced hourly rate |
| Who carries the risk of more work | You | The firm, within the scope | Shared |
| Best suited to | Disputes, investigations, open-ended advice | Plans, agreements, transactions with a known path | Claims where you are seeking money and the case is strong |
| What to watch | Monthly cost drift | What sits outside the scope | How the percentage and expenses are calculated |
Hourly on a retainer
You pay for the time spent, recorded in small units and itemised on a monthly invoice. At the start you place a deposit, the retainer, in a client account. Invoices are paid from it, and you top it up as it runs down. Any unused balance is returned at the end.
This is the right structure when nobody can see the end of the matter from the beginning. It is also the most transparent: every entry shows who did what, for how long. The disadvantage is that the total is unknown, so we pair it with a written budget by phase and tell you promptly if a phase is going to run over, before the time is spent rather than after.
Fixed fee
We agree a price for a defined piece of work, and that is what you pay, whether it takes us more hours than expected or fewer. For larger matters we break the price into stages, for example planning, drafting and signing, so you are not paying for everything up front.
The engagement letter lists exactly what is included. That list is the most important part of the arrangement. A fixed fee for an estate plan might include two meetings, the will, one trust, powers of attorney and a signing session, but not the retitling of property into the trust, which is a separate task. When something outside the list comes up, we tell you, give you a price for it, and only proceed when you agree.
Contingency and hybrid arrangements
In a contingency arrangement the firm is paid a share of whatever is recovered, and nothing, or a reduced amount, if there is no recovery. In a hybrid, you pay a reduced hourly rate throughout and the firm takes a smaller share of any recovery.
We offer these selectively. They only make sense where you are the party seeking money, the claim is well documented, and the other side is able to pay. Rules on contingency fees vary between jurisdictions and between types of matter, and some kinds of work cannot be done on this basis at all. Where it is available, the percentage, the treatment of expenses and what happens if you settle early are set out in writing before any work begins.

What a good engagement letter tells you
Whatever the structure, the engagement letter is the contract between you and the firm. It governs, not a conversation, not a proposal email and not this website. Before you sign one, check that it answers these questions in plain words:
- Who will do the work, and at what rate for each person.
- What exactly is in scope, and what is expressly left out.
- How expenses such as court fees, expert reports and travel are handled, and whether they need your approval above a certain level.
- When and how you will be invoiced, and what happens to any unused retainer.
- How either side can end the engagement.
- How the firm will tell you if the estimate is going to be exceeded.
If a letter is silent on any of these, ask. A firm that is reluctant to put its fee terms in writing is telling you something.
The best fee conversation happens before the work starts. The worst one happens after an invoice arrives that nobody expected.
How we choose which structure to propose
We do not have a house preference. After the first consultation we propose the structure that fits the matter, and we explain why. In practice:
- Planning and documents such as estate plans, shareholder agreements and executive contract reviews are usually fixed fee.
- Transactions such as the sale of a business are usually a fixed fee for defined stages, with hourly work for anything that falls outside them, such as a renegotiation late in the process.
- Disputes are usually hourly on a retainer with a phased budget, and occasionally hybrid where the claim supports it.
- Ongoing advice for a business owner can be a monthly fixed amount covering a set number of hours, reviewed every six months.
When you can ask to change it
If a matter changes shape, the structure can change too. A dispute that settles in principle can move from hourly to a fixed fee for documenting the settlement. A transaction that turns into a disagreement between buyer and seller may move the other way. Any change is agreed in writing.
Questions clients ask us about fees
Is the first consultation charged? No. We use it to understand the matter, run a conflict check and tell you whether we are the right firm. If we are, we send a written proposal afterwards.
Can I get an estimate for hourly work? Yes, and you should insist on one. It will be a range by phase, with the assumptions that drive it, and we update it when those assumptions change.
Do you negotiate? We will discuss scope before we discuss rates. Removing a task you can do yourself, such as gathering documents, is usually a better saving than a discount.
What if I disagree with an invoice? Tell us within the period stated in the engagement letter. The partner responsible reviews it personally, and entries that should not be there come off.
Fee structures are a practical matter, but they shape the whole relationship. Ask about them early, get the answer in writing, and choose the arrangement that puts the risk where it belongs.
This is general information, not legal advice. Fee rules vary by jurisdiction and matter type; your engagement letter governs.

