What happens in a first consultation with {{brand}}

Choosing an accountant: what a fixed monthly fee should cover

Scope goes wrong more often than price. Four questions to ask any firm, the line-by-line list of what our monthly fee includes and what is quoted separately, and how switching accountants works.

Marcus Ellery Avatar

·

5 min read

Owners usually start looking for a new accountant for one of three reasons: the business has outgrown a sole practitioner, the last year-end was a scramble, or an invoice arrived that nobody had discussed. Price matters, but it is rarely the thing that goes wrong. What goes wrong is scope: the owner thought something was included and the firm thought it was not. This note sets out how we would choose an accountant if we were on your side of the table, and what a fixed monthly fee from Sterling & Cole LLP does and does not cover.

Start with what you actually need

Before comparing firms, write down the work you want done. Most small and medium businesses need some combination of the following:

  • bookkeeping: recording transactions and reconciling the bank
  • payroll: running pay, payslips and the related filings
  • a monthly or quarterly close with a management pack
  • periodic sales-tax returns, where the business is registered
  • year-end accounts and the business’s tax return
  • personal tax returns for the owners
  • advice: budgeting, cash planning, pricing, funding, structure

Some of these are routine and repeat on a calendar. Advice is not. A good proposal separates the two, prices the routine work as a fixed amount, and says how advice is charged.

Four questions that separate firms

Who will do the work?

Ask for names. Many firms sell with a partner and deliver with whoever is free. Ask who prepares your books, who reviews them, who you call with a question, and what happens when that person is on leave. At our firm every client has a named lead accountant and a named reviewer, and both appear on every monthly pack.

What is the response time?

Agree it in writing. Ours is one working day for an acknowledgement and three working days for an answer to a routine question. Complex questions get a date by which we will reply, not an open promise.

What software will we use?

Most firms prefer one or two bookkeeping platforms. That is reasonable, since it keeps their work consistent, but ask what happens to your existing history if you move, who owns the subscription, and whether you keep access if you leave the firm. You should always own your own books.

What happens at year-end?

Ask how the year-end is scheduled, what the firm needs from you, and by when. A firm that runs a proper monthly close should make year-end a review rather than a reconstruction.

A partner and a client reviewing a proposal across the meeting table

What a fixed monthly fee covers with us

We price routine work as one monthly figure, reviewed once a year. The proposal lists every item. A typical scope for a trading company with a handful of staff looks like this:

Included in the monthly feeCharged separately, quoted first
Bookkeeping and bank reconciliation for agreed accountsClearing a backlog of unreconciled months
Payroll for an agreed number of staffPayroll above that number, or new pay schemes
Monthly close and management pack by working day eightBoard papers, investor reports, lender covenants
Periodic sales-tax returnsRegistrations, changes of scheme, disputes
Year-end accounts and business tax returnCompany restructures, sales, acquisitions
Two owners’ personal returnsAdditional returns, trusts, overseas income
Email and phone questions within the scope aboveProject advice: pricing studies, funding applications

The right-hand column is not a list of extras we hope to sell. It is the list of things that vary so much between clients that a fixed price would be a guess. When one comes up, we tell you, send a price, and wait for your agreement before starting.

The most useful line in any accounting proposal is the one that says what is not included. If a proposal has no such line, ask for one.

How the fee is set

We price from the volume and complexity of the work, not from turnover. The inputs are the number of bank and card accounts, the number of transactions a month, the number of staff on payroll, whether you hold stock, and whether you trade in more than one currency. We confirm the inputs with you before we quote.

The fee is reviewed once a year against the same inputs. If your transactions have doubled, we show you the numbers and propose a new figure. If they have fallen, the fee comes down. There are no mid-year increases without a change you asked for.

What we ask of you in return

A fixed fee only works if the inputs arrive on time. We ask clients to connect bank feeds, upload receipts as they go, send payroll changes before the payroll cut-off, and answer our monthly questions within a working day. Where that does not happen for several months running, we raise it with you before we raise the fee.

Switching from your current accountant

Changing firms is more routine than most owners expect. The steps are:

  1. Agree the scope and fee with the new firm and sign the engagement letter.
  2. Give the new firm written authority to contact the old one.
  3. The new firm requests the prior-year accounts, returns, working papers and software access.
  4. Your old firm finishes any work already in progress, or hands it over, as agreed.
  5. The new firm runs a short review of the opening balances before the first monthly close.

We usually suggest switching at the start of a quarter, and never in the four weeks before a filing deadline.

Questions owners ask

Do you charge for the first meeting? No. It lasts up to an hour, and we use it to understand the business and tell you whether we are a good fit.

Can we keep our current bookkeeper and use you for the rest? Yes. We then quote for the review, close and year-end only, with an agreed standard for the bookkeeping we receive.

What if we disagree with an invoice? Tell your lead accountant. Anything outside the agreed scope that was not approved in advance comes off.

To talk through your current arrangement, write to counsel@example.com or call (212) 555-0187 during Mon–Fri 8:30–18:00, by appointment.

This is general information, not accounting or tax advice. Your engagement letter sets out the actual scope and fee.