What happens in a first consultation with {{brand}}

How we scope a consulting engagement before we price it

Start from the decision, not the topic. The two unbilled weeks before a proposal, the six headings every scope document carries, and why we sometimes recommend a smaller first phase than the one you asked for.

Catherine Hale Avatar

·

5 min read

Most consulting engagements that disappoint were scoped badly, not delivered badly. The team did what the proposal said; the proposal answered a different question from the one the client needed answered. At Sterling & Cole LLP we spend more time on scoping than most clients expect, usually two or three conversations over about two weeks, and we do not charge for it. This note explains what happens in those two weeks, what a scope document contains, and why we sometimes recommend a smaller engagement than the one you asked for.

Start from the decision, not the topic

A client rarely arrives with a scope. They arrive with a topic: “our margins”, “the new market”, “the operations team”. A topic cannot be delivered. A decision can.

So the first question we ask is: what decision will you make differently at the end of this work? Close a site or keep it. Enter a market this year, next year, or not at all. Restructure a team or invest in it. If nobody can name the decision, the engagement is not ready, and we would rather tell you that in the first meeting than in week eight.

Who owns the decision

The second question is who makes that decision, and who can block it. An engagement sponsored by a finance director but dependent on the operations director’s data needs both people in the scoping conversation. If they are not, we ask for them.

The two weeks of scoping

StepTimingWhat happens
First conversationDay 1The decision, the sponsor, the deadline, what has been tried before
Document requestDays 2–5A short list of existing reports, data and prior studies
Second conversationAround day 7We test the question with the sponsor and one or two others
Draft scopeAround day 10A four-page document, sent for comment
Final proposalAround day 14Scope, team, timeline, fee and assumptions, ready to sign

None of this is billed. If at any point either side concludes the work is not right for us, we say so and stop.

A working session: sticky notes and a question written across a whiteboard

What a scope document contains

Our scope documents are short on purpose. Each one has the same six headings:

  • The question. One sentence, ending in a question mark.
  • The decision it informs. Who will decide, and roughly when.
  • In scope. The analysis, interviews, sites, markets or units we will cover.
  • Out of scope. What we will not look at, named explicitly.
  • Deliverables. What you will receive, in what form, and on which dates.
  • Assumptions. The data, access and people we need from you, and by when.

The out-of-scope heading carries more weight than it appears. “We will not assess the sales team” or “we will use your existing cost allocations rather than rebuild them” prevents a far longer conversation in week six.

A scope is a promise about what you will know at the end. If it reads like a list of activities, it has not been finished.

Assumptions are part of the price

Every fee we quote rests on assumptions: that data arrives within an agreed number of days, that named people are available for interviews, that the question does not change. When an assumption fails, it changes what the work costs or when it finishes. Writing assumptions down means we can have that conversation calmly, with the document on the table, rather than as a surprise.

Why we sometimes recommend less

About one scoping conversation in four ends with us proposing a smaller first phase than the client asked for. Usually it is because the question depends on a fact nobody has yet established. If the real issue is whether a product line makes money at all, there is little point designing its growth plan until that is known.

In those cases we propose a short diagnostic, often three or four weeks, with its own deliverable and its own fee. At the end you decide whether to continue, with us or without us. Our experience is that clients who start with a diagnostic spend less overall and argue less about what the later work should cover.

How change is handled once work begins

Questions move. A board meeting shifts a priority; a finding in week three opens a door nobody expected. We handle it in three steps:

  1. We raise the change in writing within two working days of spotting it.
  2. We set out what it would add or replace, and what it does to the timeline and fee.
  3. Nothing changes until the sponsor agrees in writing.

Sometimes the right answer is to swap one piece of work for another at no change in fee. Sometimes it is a short extension. Occasionally it is to finish the current scope and start a new engagement afterwards.

What the fee is built from

The fee in the final proposal is built from the scope, not the other way round. We estimate the team and the number of weeks each part of the work needs, add the time for interviews, analysis and reviews with your sponsor, and then decide whether a fixed price or time and materials fits better. A defined question with a known path usually becomes a fixed price, paid in stages tied to the deliverables. Work whose shape is still moving, such as supporting a negotiation, is usually time and materials with a monthly cap that cannot be exceeded without your written agreement. Either way the proposal shows how the figure was reached, so you can see what would change it and where a smaller scope would save money.

What to bring to the first conversation

You do not need a brief. It helps if you can tell us:

  • the decision and the date by which it needs to be made
  • what has already been tried, internally or with other advisers
  • who else in the business cares about the answer
  • any constraint we should know about early: budget, timing, confidentiality

Write to counsel@example.com or call (212) 555-0187 and a partner will come back to you within one working day to arrange a time.

This describes how we work in general. The signed proposal for your engagement sets out the actual scope, fee and terms.